UPDATE: Additional links
flickrvision – real time view of images uploaded to Flickr. The location is where the image was uploaded from.
Examples of embedding images from a photo-sharing site. It includes two sizes of a Google slide show, and three versions of a Flickr badge.
Some Observations About Photo-sharing
I provide a sample of links to discussions about on-line photo-sharing below, and you can see that it has been well covered in the blogosphere. Why am I contributing to the discussion now? Simply, we haven’t discussed it here and the primary purpose of this blog is to present applications that could be of use in our library.
There are billions of images stored in on-line photo-sharing services. As of now, as I type this sentence, PhotoBucket has 2.85 billion images and Yahoo Photos also has over two billion images. Photo-sharing services range from the simple “here they are, come look at them, and maybe buy some prints” to services that have sophisticated searching, secret algorithms to create subject clusters and most interesting rankings based on viewer habits, the capability to assign levels of permission for the use of images, send images to other services such as blogs, and organize images in ways meaningful to the creator.
I mentioned Yahoo Photos in the last paragraph. Yahoo also owns Flickr and recently announced that Yahoo Photos is being phased out in favor of Flickr. Flickr had only 500 million images but has been growing faster than Yahoo Photos. Yahoo is taking an interesting approach to their existing Photos accounts. With one touch, the photos of Yahoo members can be moved to a Flickr account. Yahoo will help those who choose to not to take the Flickr option to move their images to another service, such as PhotoBucket. It will be interesting to see how this shakes out. Flickr has restrictions on the number of images that can be displayed in an free account and restricts the number of images that can be uploaded per month. Yahoo Photos didn’t have that restriction.
In other industry changes, MySpace just bought PhotoBucket. PhotoBucket is the main supplier of photos to MySpace.
Basic accounts are free so it is easy to test drive before you commit. You could also maintain several accounts. Perhaps you want one account just to share photos with family and friends and another where you keep all your photos.
Which Photo-sharing service do I like?
There are three services that stand out for me: Flickr, Zooomr, and Picasa. Flickr is owned by Yahoo. Zooomr appeared in 2006 and is looked by industry pundits as a serious rival to Flickr. I believe the founder was 17 at the time. Picasa is owned by Google and thus fits into their suite of services available with a single login. Picasa also has a desktop client that allows you to organize and modify images which you can selectively upload.
In terms of number of web features, Flikr is first, then Zooomr, then Picasa. Of the three, only Zooomr doesn’t have a print purchase service. All three have free and pro accounts. Zooomr has nifty approach with pro accounts: You can get a free pro account if you are a blogger. I started a pro account with Flickr but I’m watching Zooomr.
What’s Interesting About Photo-sharing
People like to look at pictures. People want to share photos with friends and family. People might wonder if other people will like their photographs. OK, granted, these by themselves are not all that interesting. What about making connections? I have several photographs take when I was stationed in Viet Nam. Someone searched on my unit designation and found my photos. He gave me information about what happened to my unit after I left. This is part of what intrigues me about photo-sharing, the added value that on-line photo-sharing can bring to an image. This value is twofold. First, people can add tags, comments, notes, locations on maps to their work and, in some cases the work of others – metadata. Second, the photo-sharing site can take all the information provided by people about an image, mix in what they can determine about how users interact with images and other users, and develop ways of ranking and clustering images. The end result is that access to the image is not static but dynamic and made much more accessible. Flickr is the only service that I know of that takes metadata and combines it with user behaviors to produce a feature that guides a person to other images they may like.
Consider tagging, a concept librarians are trying to come to terms with – people providing their own descriptive terms for an item and not using a controlled vocabulary. A lot of photo-sharing services allow the owner to tag an image. Flickr allows a member to grant permission to tag to friends, family, or everyone. When everyone can tag, you get interesting interpretations of a work. For example, let’s say I post a photograph of my cat and I tag it “cat.” Someone else might view the photograph and notice the cat’s whiskers and add the “whisker” tag. Is the cat asleep? On its back? Is there a marking on the nose? All of these are legitimate descriptors from someone’s point of view. Access to this image has been greatly extended. Tim Spalding over at LibraryThing makes a similar point about tagging books. Bridgit Jones’s Diary is tagged with the non-LCSH term “Chic Lit.” That term is used by other people for other titles. Searching for the tag Chic Lit” will get the user a bibliography of book in this user defined genre. Tim has interesting things to say about tagging. Take a look at When tags work and when they don’t: Amazon and LibraryThing and Percent who tag. It will be interesting to seeif/when tagging makes the jump to traditional library services, such as the catalog.
Flickr is the standout service for librarians. I believe this is true because Flickr adds the most value to an image and provides the most access points to an image.
We want to find ways to direct people to our services. Is Flicker a means to that end?
Value Added to Images Through On-Line Photo-Sharing: a Flick-centric Look
I will indicate which service does not have a feature by using -F, -Z, and -P for Flickr, Zooomr, and Picasa.
- Share images on-line
- Public, private, to selected groups such as friends and family
- allow users to define what the image means to them through tagging
- add a comment to an image
- add notes to areas of an image (-P)
- mark image as a favorite (-P limited to members, not individual images)
- be alerted when new images are added
- make the images available to other services such as blogs
- place an image on a map (geo tagging)
- advanced searching capabilities (-Z, -P)
- dynamically generate tag clusters(-Z, -P)
- dynamically determine how interesting an image might be to viewers (-Z, -P)
- Create groups (-Z, -P)
- Place image on map
- Create slide shows (-Z)
- Picasa provides code for embedding flash slideshow
- Flickr doesn’t officially support embedding slideshows on other sites
- Assign Creative Commons license to an image (-P)
- Flickr has a search filter to limit search results to images with a CC license
- Newbie’s Guide to Flickr
- Why is Flickr Afraid of Zoomr
- 2007 Photo Sharing Services Reviews
- Photobucket vs. flickr in Alexa and Technorati
- Online Photo-Sharing Services
- The Flickr Gunners
- Web Photo Sharing Site Faceoff
- Libraries and Flickr – South Carolina State Library
- Flickr Tutorials – S.C. Libraries
- Applications of Flickr in Libraries – look half way down the page – Information Wants to be Free
- Flickr Tagging, and the F-Word – Librarian.net
- Flickr & Libraries – Librarian in Black
- Flickr for Academic Libraries – Library 2.0
- Using Flickr @ Reading Public Library – Library Techtonics
- Finding Focus on Flickr -Library Techtonics
- Tagging on Flickr and del.icio.us – Library Techtonics
- Meet our staff … and Flickr – Connect with the Campus Library
- Flickr and Libraries – Moving at the Speed of Creativity
- Ten More Reasons to Use Flickr in Your Libraries (updated) – Tame the Web
- Steal This Idea: Flickr for Libraries – Tame the Web
- Why Flickr is so Great for Libraries – The Shifted Librarian
- Flickr is the Web Photo Tool Preferred by Superheroes and Libraries – The Tao of Law Librarianship
- The hazards of letting people use your Flickr photo – Travelin’ Librarian
- Get Flickr-tastic – WebJunction
- Social Networking, Flickr, and MMOGs – Five Weeks to a Social Library
- Flickr + Library = Scary, Scary, Scary
Examples of Flickr in Libraries
- Swem Library Tag in Flickr
- Special Collections Research Center’s photos
- Georgia State University
- 365 Library Days Project
- MA Libraries
- Dublin Cities Public Libraries photos
- Libraries of The Claremont Colleges’ Photos
- zsrlibrary’s photos
- Libraries with Flickr Accounts
- Lansing Celebrity READ Posters
- Library Book Cards
- American Libraries Flickr Page
- Libraries that use Flickr
- University of Delaware Library
- University of Winnipeg Library Virtual Tour
- University of Winnipeg Library Slide Show on Flickr
- Santa Rosa Junior College
Photo Sharing Sites – A sampling